Experiments on wave dissipation performance of a new seawall ecological armour block

LI Xiaoyan, YE Junwei, SHEN Jiafa, LUO Zhiwei, ZHENG Xin, ZHAO Haitao

Journal of Marine Sciences ›› 2025, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (3) : 49-59.

PDF(8993 KB)
PDF(8993 KB)
Journal of Marine Sciences ›› 2025, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (3) : 49-59. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-909X.2025.03.006

Experiments on wave dissipation performance of a new seawall ecological armour block

Author information +
History +

Abstract

The new seawall ecological armour block is a type of face protection structure with both excellent wave dissipation performance and ecological function. In order to systematically evaluate its wave dissipation performance, this study carried out a two-dimensional wave flume physical modeling test using Zhoujiayuanshan Island in Zhoushan as the engineering background. The test systematically investigated the effects of wave period, wave height, relative water depth, wave steepness, breaking parameter, and block geometry (outer diameter and height), as well as model materials on the reflection coefficients under the action of regular waves. The results show that: firstly, the feasibility of using polypropylene random copolymer (PP-R) instead of foamed concrete in the physical modeling test is verified through the comparison experiments of nine working conditions, and the average difference in their reflection coefficient is only 1.17%. Secondly, for its wave dissipation performance, the reflection coefficient increases with increasing wave period, relative water depth and breaking parameter, and decreases with increasing wave height and wave steepness. Among all the tested conditions, the two types of blocks with outer diameter 7.5 cm-height 10 cm and outer diameter 10 cm-height 6.5 cm have the best wave dissipation performance, with average reflection coefficients of 0.395 and 0.382, respectively. Finally, the reflection coefficient formula for the six types of blocks is fitted based on the experimental data in this study. The formula has a root mean square error (RMSE) of 0.106 9, which is of high accuracy and our study can provide a certain reference for related engineering design.

Key words

new seawall / ecological armour block / physical modelling test / reflection coefficient / wave dissipation performance

Cite this article

Download Citations
LI Xiaoyan , YE Junwei , SHEN Jiafa , et al . Experiments on wave dissipation performance of a new seawall ecological armour block[J]. Journal of Marine Sciences. 2025, 43(3): 49-59 https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-909X.2025.03.006

References

[1]
CHO Y H, ZHANG C, NAKAMURA T, et al. Failure mechanism of armor blocks of submerged breakwater[J]. Journal of Coastal Research, 2018, 85(sp1): 1166-1170.
[2]
HOSSEINZADEH N, GHIASIAN M, ANDIROGLU E, et al. Concrete seawalls: A review of load considerations, ecological performance, durability, and recent innovations[J]. Ecological Engineering, 2022, 178: 106573.
[3]
VAN GENT M R A, LUIS L. Application of cubes in a single layer[C]//6th International Short Course/Conference on Applied Coastal Research, 2013.
[4]
MACIÑEIRA E G, BURCHARTH H F. Stability of cube armoured roundheads exposed to long crested and short crested waves[J]. Coastal Engineering, 2016, 112: 99-112.
[5]
COMOLA F, LYKKE ANDERSEN T, MARTINELLI L, et al. Damage pattern and damage progression on breakwater roundheads under multidirectional waves[J]. Coastal Engineering, 2014, 83: 24-35.
[6]
戈龙仔, 高峰, 陈汉宝. 深水防波堤新型消浪护面块体开发及其性能参数测试研究[J]. 海岸工程, 2020, 39(3):204-212.
GE L Z, GAO F, CHEN H B. New shaped wave dissipating and armor block for deepwater breakwater and its performance parameter testing[J]. Coastal Engineering, 2020, 39(3): 204-212.
[7]
ZANUTTIGH B, VAN DER MEER J W. Wave reflection from coastal structures in design conditions[J]. Coastal Engineering, 2008, 55(10): 771-779.
[8]
房伟, 陈国平, 严士常, 等. 堆石防波堤不规则波浪反射系数试验研究[J]. 海洋工程, 2017, 35(5):125-131.
FANG W, CHEN G P, YAN S C, et al. Experimental research of wave reflection coefficient on rubble mound breakwaters under irregular waves[J]. The Ocean Engineering, 2017, 35(5): 125-131.
[9]
高抒, 贾建军, 于谦. 绿色海堤的沉积地貌与生态系统动力学原理:研究综述[J]. 热带海洋学报, 2022, 41(4):1-19.
Abstract
绿色海堤是传统结构工程与海岸生态系统共同组合而成的新型海堤, 用以应对未来海面上升、风暴加剧给低地海岸防护带来的挑战。需解决的问题主要有海岸生态系统消浪过程及生态系统在海堤体系中的配置方式。理论分析、现场观测、物模数模所获结果表明, 海岸生态系统确有显著的消浪功能: 1) 陆架泥区消浪, 其机制以再悬浮和浮泥运动为主, 底部摩擦为次; 2) 潮滩下部的粉砂细砂滩底部摩擦和推移质运动共同造成波能耗散, 而上部的泥滩则以再悬浮和悬沙输运为主; 3) 在盐沼、红树林、海草床等由植被构成的生态系统, 植物通过形态阻力、茎秆运动来阻滞水流、耗散波能, 其效能高于沉积物床面对波能的耗散; 4) 生物礁主要有珊瑚礁和牡蛎礁, 其消能作用主要通过床面摩擦和波浪破碎, 效能较高, 尤其是在风暴期间。生态系统如何成为海堤的有机组成部分, 尤其是侵蚀型海岸的生态位修复和绿色海堤整体设计, 还需进一步研究相关的科学问题: 与硬质工程结合的盐沼-牡蛎礁的适应性生物学; 未来环境变化条件下生态系统的稳定性; 绿色海堤生态系统空间配置及其与风暴事件的时间尺度匹配; 基于均衡剖面理论的海堤形态优化。
GAO S, JIA J J, YU Q. Green sea dykes: An overview of their principles of sediment, geomorphology and ecosystem dynamics[J]. Journal of Tropical Oceanography, 2022, 41(4): 1-19.

Green sea dyke represents a new concept of coastal defense, which combines traditional engineering structure with coastal ecosystem, to cope with the future trend of sea level rise and storm intensification. Before its application, however, the feasibility of such a system must be tested for low-lying coastal areas, where the risk of storm surge, storm-induced waves and shoreline erosion is greatest. The major issue is associated with the process of wave attenuation by the ecosystem and the way of using the ecosystem within the sea dyke system. For many years, wave energy dissipation has been an important research field for tidal flats, a typical environment of low-lying coasts, as well as beaches and rocky coast environments. Theoretical analysis, field observation and physical-mathematical modelling show that the coastal ecosystem indeed plays a significant role in wave energy dissipation: (1) resuspension and fluid mud movement dominate over bed friction in the mud area, in terms of wave height reduction; (2) wave attenuation occurs due to bed friction and bedload transport on the silt-sand flat at the lower part of the tidal flat, while on the upper mudflat it is caused mainly by re-suspension and suspended, fine-grained sediment transport; (3) in the vegetated ecosystems such as salt marsh, mangrove and seagrass beds, the efficiency of plants in reducing flow velocity and dissipating wave energy is higher than that of bare flats, due to plant morphological resistance and stem movement; and (4) wave attenuation is high when passing through biological reefs (e.g., coral and oyster reefs), especially during storms, with bed surface friction and wave breaking being the major mechanisms. Although the wave attenuation theory has been established, the optimization of the way the ecosystem is used within the sea dyke system requires further investigations, especially the techniques of ecological niche reconstruction on eroding coasts and the design of the sea dyke to improve structure safety. The relevant scientific problems include: adaptive biology for salt marsh plants and oysters in conjunction with hard engineering; stability of ecosystem in response to future environmental change; spatial configuration of ecosystem in the green sea dyke and the match between the ecosystem life cycle and the temporal scales of storm events; and the optimization of the sea dyke configuration, on the basis of the equilibrium coastal profile theory.

[10]
MA Y X, ZHU L H, PENG Z, et al. Wave attenuation by flattened vegetation (Scirpus mariqueter)[J]. Frontiers in Marine Science, 2023, 10: 1106070.
[11]
BOUMA T J, DE VRIES M B, LOW E, et al. Flow hydrodynamics on a mudflat and in salt marsh vegetation: Identifying general relationships for habitat characterisations[J]. Hydrobiologia, 2005, 540(1): 259-274.
[12]
ANDERSON M E, SMITH J M. Wave attenuation by flexible, idealized salt marsh vegetation[J]. Coastal Engineering, 2014, 83: 82-92.
[13]
MAZA M, LARA J L, LOSADA I J. A paradigm shift in the quantification of wave energy attenuation due to saltmarshes based on their standing biomass[J]. Scientific Reports, 2022, 12(1): 13883.
Most existing analytical and numerical models to quantify wave energy attenuation attributed to saltmarshes are based on the definition of a drag coefficient that varies with vegetation and wave characteristics and requires calibration, i.e., a case-specific variable. With the aim of determining a new variable to estimate wave energy attenuation without the use of calibration coefficients, wave attenuation caused by different saltmarsh species and the relationship with the ecosystem standing biomass are experimentally studied. Samples of four real saltmarshes with contrasting morphological and biomechanical properties, namely, Spartina sp., Salicornia sp., Halimione sp. and Juncus sp., are collected in the field and placed in a wave flume for testing under different regular and random wave conditions. Two meadow densities are considered, in addition to zero-density cases. Thus, wave damping coefficients are obtained in vegetated cases, β, and bare soil cases, β, and wave damping produced solely by the meadow standing biomass, β, is determined. The obtained wave damping coefficients are related to a new variable, the hydraulic standing biomass (HSB), which is defined as a function of the meadow mean height and standing biomass and incident flow characteristics. Linear fitting relationships between the wave damping coefficient and HSB are obtained, allowing β and β estimation without the need for calibration. Therefore, the use of these new relationships facilitates direct quantification of wave energy attenuation due to saltmarshes based on incident wave conditions, mean plant height and meadow standing biomass, variables that can be obtained from aerial images or remote sensing data, extending the applicability of the approach. Another key aspect is that this approach does not depend on any calibration coefficient and can be directly applied with knowledge of the abovementioned characteristics. This may represent a paradigm shift in the estimation of wave energy attenuation attributed to saltmarshes.© 2022. The Author(s).
[14]
GODA Y, SUZUKI Y. Estimation of incident and reflected waves in random wave experiments[C]//15th International Conference on Coastal Engineering, 1976: 828-845.
[15]
水运工程模拟试验技术规范: JTS/T 231—2021[S]. 北京: 人民交通出版社, 2021.
Technical code of modelling test for port and waterway engineering: JTS/T 231—2021[S]. Beijing: China Communications Press, 2021.
[16]
MUTTRAY M, OUMERACI H, TEN OEVER E. Wave reflection and wave run-up at rubble mound breakwaters[C]//30th ICCE, 2006: 4314-4324.
[17]
SCHOONEES T, KERPEN N B, SCHLURMANN T. Full-scale experimental study on wave reflection and run-up at stepped revetments[J]. Coastal Engineering, 2022, 172: 104045.
[18]
ZHAO H T, YE J W, DONG S D, et al. Numerical modelling of the spatial distribution of wave overtopping water behind dikes under regular wave action using OpenFOAM[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2024, 309: 118551.
[19]
PENG C, WANG H, ZHANG H Q, et al. Parametric design and numerical investigation of hydrodynamic characteristics of a new type of armour block TB-CUBE based on SPH method[J]. Journal of Marine Science Engineering, 2022, 10: 1116.
[20]
彭程, 王昊, 娄雅冬, 等. 斜坡堤新型人工块体TB-CUBE的波浪爬高和反射试验研究[J]. 水运工程, 2022(9):1-7.
PENG C, WANG H, LOU Y D, et al. Experiment investigation on wave run-up and reflection of a new artificial block TB-CUBE for sloping breakwater[J]. Port & Waterway Engineering, 2022(9): 1-7.
[21]
VAN DER MEER J W, ALLSOP N W H, BRUCE T, et al. Manual on wave overtopping of sea defences and related structures: An overtopping manual largely based on European research, but for worldwide application[M]. [S.l.]: EurOtop, 2018.
PDF(8993 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/